Dearest Friends,

It was delightful to be in your gracious company in our most recent gathering.

In our last session, we explored our experiences of ecological guilt, focusing on the suffering that arises when we’re acutely aware of our ongoing participation in systems that perpetuate ecological harm (e.g., our reliance on fossil fuels, our contribution to carbon emissions, our dependence on industrial agriculture, etc.).

In the reflections that I offered, I drew on Karla McLaren’s valuable distinction between guilt and shame. From Ms. McLaren’s perspective, guilt isn’t an emotion—it’s the recognition of wrongdoing. For example, ecological guilt arises when we recognize that our actions (e.g., traveling by plane, buying fast fashion, eating industrially produced food, etc.) are factually tied to harm. We are “guilty” in relation to ecological ethics because we participate in systems that are injurious to the planet.

Ms. McLaren then goes on to clarify that shame is the emotion that follows guilt. It’s the sincere aspiration to avoid acting in ways that harm the planet or betray our values. Ecological shame can feel acutely painful, but Ms. McLaren reframes it as a guide that supports us in restoring our integrity and living in alignment with our ecological conscience. From an ecological perspective, shame can offer the following gifts:

  • Conscientiousness: Shame helps us stay sensitive to the impact of our actions on non-human life and future generations.
  • Integrity: Shame supports us in aligning more closely with our ecological values and continually finding ways to express this alignment within very real systemic constraints.
  • Atonement: Shame supports us in engaging in reparation, e.g., reducing our consumption, recycling our waste, advocating for change, etc.

In short, when we befriend our ecological shame, we can prevent it from devolving into punitive self-loathing and lean on it as a valuable ally that reminds us of what we cherish the most—and supports us in engaging in restoration and repair.

SUGGESTED PRACTICE:

Sit quietly and take a few moments to attend to your breath. Then silently work with the following prompts:

  • Acknowledging Guilt: Which of my daily actions contribute to ecological harm? Where do I feel complicit in systems that damage the Earth?
  • Meeting Shame with Curiosity: How does my body feel when I think about the ecological harm I’ve participated in? What values of mine are being undermined when my actions harm the Earth?
  • Exploring Commitments: Do I hold myself to an impossible commitment (e.g., “I must never harm the Earth at all”)? What would a compassionate commitment look like—one that honors my values but also recognizes the constraints within which I operate?
  • Inviting the Gifts of Shame: What small acts of atonement can I take today? How might I restore integrity in my ecological choices? What behavioral changes feel both possible and meaningful?
  • Releasing Punitive Shame: Where am I punishing myself instead of listening to shame’s guidance? How can I transform shame into a compass rather than a cage?

To conclude, offer gratitude to your shame for its forthright vigilance. End the meditation with these words: May my shame serve life. May it protect this precious planet and its equally precious inhabitants. 

REFLECTION PROMPTS:

  1. What forms of ecological guilt show up most strongly in your life?
  2. How has ecological shame helped you realign with and stay truer to your ecological values?
  3. What commitments can you take on that balance conscience with compassion?
  4. What can support you in honoring shame’s gifts without being overwhelmed by its weight?
  5. What acts of ecological atonement do you feel invited to engage in, whether on a personal or collective level?

Discover more from The Lotus Pod

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Eileen Fulache Tupaz, PhD Avatar

Published by

Leave a Reply